top of page

How the Exploitation of Hispanic Labor Enabled the Stage for Crisis and Accountability

Writer's picture: Charles JohnsonCharles Johnson

America’s Labor Shift: The Reckoning of an Economic Butterfly Effect


ICE, Roof Top Arrests, Mass Deportation & Arlington Roofer
ICE, Roof Top Arrests, Mass Deportation & Arlington Roofer

The Unfolding Reckoning: A Storm Long in the Making


I did say this was going to happen.


For decades, America’s blue-collar industries rode the wave of cheap, disposable labor, convinced that the consequences of their choices would never circle back to them. Business owners reaped the benefits of an underpaid, undocumented workforce while native-born workers, particularly white men, were priced out—not because they lacked the work ethic, but because they had the audacity to demand fair wages. And so, the economy adjusted accordingly: those who charged less became the backbone of the workforce, and those who charged more were deemed replaceable.


But nothing in history is without consequence.


By making Hispanic labor the backbone of key industries—construction, roofing, agriculture—business owners not only reshaped the labor market but also sowed the seeds of an underground economy rife with exploitation and crime. The Cartel. Today, as the Trump administration’s deportation policies attempt to undo decades of systemic dependence on immigrant labor, the economic and humanitarian fallout is undeniable. What we are witnessing is not just an immigration crisis, nor merely an economic shift—it is the predictable consequence of a system built on unsustainable foundations. Large corporate roofing companies, though not the only ones, systematically enabled it.


This is the reckoning.


The Strategic Displacement of Native Labor


The narrative has always been framed the same way: immigrants take jobs that Americans won’t do. But the truth is, Americans—white, Black, and otherwise—did these jobs before wages were systematically lowered to accommodate a cheaper workforce. And, they were craftsmen.


Take the roofing industry, for example. In the 1980s, roofing crews in Oklahoma, Texas, and California were predominantly native-born workers. They were skilled, unionized in many cases, and commanded fair wages. But as undocumented labor surged, the numbers shifted. Business owners, driven not by some cultural preference but by the cold calculus of profit, chose to replace them. Why pay a native-born worker $25 an hour when you can pay an undocumented laborer $12 under the table?


This wasn’t about laziness. It wasn’t about Americans refusing to work for exploitative wages. It was about an economic incentive to undercut wages—a classic race to the bottom. And those at the bottom were exploited, first for their labor and later, for their vulnerability.


Debt Bondage and the Darker Cost of Cheap Labor


Debt Bondage & North Texas: Roofer or Cartel
Debt Bondage & North Texas: Roofer or Cartel

There is a direct line—an economic butterfly effect—between the decision to prioritize cheap labor and the modern crisis of human trafficking, debt bondage, child exploitation, rape, and murder.

Today, an estimated 60% of undocumented laborers arrive in the U.S. under a system of debt bondage. Smugglers, cartels, and human traffickers finance their passage, demanding years of servitude in return. Many never escape. Some—especially children—fall into even darker fates: sexual exploitation, forced labor, or murder at the hands of traffickers.

This is not a side effect. This is the cost of a system that deliberately created a demand for undocumented workers while pretending their exploitation was someone else’s problem. Every business owner who chose to pay an undocumented worker less instead of hiring a native-born worker at a fair wage played a role. They may not have trafficked a child themselves, but they helped create an economy that made it profitable.


And now, the reckoning is here.


The Trump Administration’s Hard Reset: A Solution or a New Crisis?

Trump’s crackdown on undocumented labor was inevitable—an overdue reaction to an unsustainable status quo. But will it actually solve anything?


Mass deportations created an immediate labor vacuum, particularly in roofing, construction, and agriculture. But those jobs didn’t return to native-born workers. Why?


  • Wages remained too low. Few Americans were willing to work under conditions that had been normalized for undocumented workers.

  • Skill gaps emerged. Many native-born workers had long since abandoned these industries, leaving a workforce gap that couldn't be filled overnight.

  • Business owners resisted change. Many of the same companies that had profited from cheap labor for decades struggled to operate without it.


The historical parallels are striking. The Mexican Repatriation of the 1930s sent thousands of Mexican workers back to Mexico, only for the U.S. to reinvite them through the Bracero Program a decade later when labor shortages crippled the economy. Will history repeat itself once again?


The Media’s Role in the Narrative War


The labor crisis has been spun in every direction, depending on the political agenda:

  • The right-wing narrative: Immigrants steal jobs. Deport them to make America great again.

  • The left-wing narrative: Deportation is cruel. Immigrants do the work Americans refuse to do.


Neither tells the full truth. The problem was never the workers. The problem was the economy that deliberately made their exploitation the most profitable choice. The real issue isn’t about border walls or sanctuary cities—it’s about a country that allowed its labor force to be quietly replaced for the sake of higher margins.


America at a Crossroads: Lessons from Collapsed Civilizations


History is filled with warnings for nations that lose control of their labor markets:


  • Ancient Rome: Outsourced its military and labor to Germanic tribes → Germanic tribes took over.

  • Industrial Britain: Allowed foreign textile labor to undercut its industries → Economic decline.

  • The U.S. Manufacturing Crisis: Outsourced factory jobs to China in the 1980s → Permanent loss of middle-class manufacturing.


America’s blue-collar industries are now at a breaking point. The choice is clear:


  1. Adaptation Model:

    • Regulate and stabilize immigrant labor.

    • Invest in vocational training for native-born workers.

    • Establish legal work visa programs to prevent underground exploitation.

  2. Decline Model:

    • Continue relying on undocumented labor while politically opposing it.

    • See further wage collapse and working-class disenfranchisement.

    • Repeat the mistakes of fallen empires.


VII. The Final Reckoning: Accountability Is Coming



There’s no undoing what has already happened. The damage is real. The question is not whether America can return to a pre-immigration labor market—that ship has sailed. The question is whether America will finally take responsibility for the economy it created.


  • Will business owners be held accountable for decades of illegal labor practices?

  • Will policymakers finally address labor shortages with real solutions instead of reactionary deportations?

  • Will American workers reclaim industries, or will new immigrant business owners control them?


One thing is certain: the fantasy that America could exploit labor indefinitely without consequence is over. The bills have come due.



About the author

Ambassador Charles StClair: A Life of Service, Advocacy, and Integrity

Charles StClair is a dedicated humanitarian, advocate, and industry leader whose work spans international diplomacy, human rights, and business integrity. In 2012, he served as an Ambassador to the United Nations for the Freedom Fighters of West Papua, championing the cause of self-determination and human rights for the people of the region.

Recognized for his unwavering commitment to justice, Charles was awarded the title of Knight Commander for his humanitarian efforts in combatting child trafficking. His work in field operations and remote support has played a crucial role in rescuing and protecting vulnerable children from exploitation.

Beyond his diplomatic and humanitarian efforts, Charles has established himself as a roofing contractor and insurance adjuster, bringing leadership, resilience, and integrity to the industry. His work in life training, journalism, and authorship further amplifies his mission to inform, educate, and empower others. As a published author, he explores themes of consciousness, human potential, and systemic transformation.

Married for 31 years and a proud father of three children, Charles embodies the values of family, perseverance, and legacy. He continues to advocate for ethical solutions in industries plagued by corruption, using his expertise to challenge injustices and drive meaningful change.

His life is a testament to courage, advocacy, and a relentless pursuit of truth—whether on the global stage, in the fight against human trafficking, or within industry sectors where integrity is needed most.

13 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page